Because Christian appeared to Claire when she woke up in the jungle, before she left Aron and followed him.
I mean, Claire and Christian being manifestations of anti-Jacob would work if we only had the cabin scene with them convincing Locke to move the island, but the meeting and conversation between Claire and her father doesn't make any sense if they are both avatars of the unnamed man.
Or was Christian a ghosty agent speaking for Jacob but not able, like Richard, to recognize the anti-Jacob in Claire?
The thing is that it would work better if Christian was the anti-Jacob for it's quite similar to the Locke situation. Both Christian Sheperd and John Locke died outside the island but their corpse were on the plane so their body ended up on the island.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
branchandroot
no subject
Date: 2009-05-16 05:31 pm (UTC)I mean, Claire and Christian being manifestations of anti-Jacob would work if we only had the cabin scene with them convincing Locke to move the island, but the meeting and conversation between Claire and her father doesn't make any sense if they are both avatars of the unnamed man.
Or was Christian a ghosty agent speaking for Jacob but not able, like Richard, to recognize the anti-Jacob in Claire?
The thing is that it would work better if Christian was the anti-Jacob for it's quite similar to the Locke situation. Both Christian Sheperd and John Locke died outside the island but their corpse were on the plane so their body ended up on the island.